Why Innovation Gets Stuck: The Real Cost of Playing It Safe

Organizations love to talk about innovation, but they often fall short when it comes to actually doing it. This post explores how a commitment to competence and safety undermines real innovation—and what you can do to break the pattern. If your team is full of smart, creative people who rarely take risks or test new ideas, you might be stuck in “Incomplete Innovation.”

Innovation is the darling of corporate strategy decks everywhere. It shows up in vision statements, gets name-dropped in town halls, and might even be tattooed on your values wall. But here’s the kicker: a lot of organizations that say they love innovation aren’t actually doing much of it. They’re innovating in theory—not in practice.

We call this culture pattern Incomplete Innovation. It happens when organizations fully embrace the concepts of innovation (creativity, future-focus, inspiration) but neglect the actual practices that drive it forward—things like risk-taking, experimentation, and testing new ideas.

Why does this happen? Because the drive to create new value is often neutralized by a competing commitment: looking competent. No one wants to be the person who tried something and failed. No one wants to be seen as “the one with the bad idea.” And so, slowly but surely, innovation gets replaced with optimization. We don’t test bold hypotheses; we A/B test the subject line.

Innovation Theater: Signs You’re Faking It

If any of this sounds familiar, you’re not alone. Here are a few signs your organization might be stuck in Incomplete Innovation:

• Experiments are rare (and when they happen, they’re so safe they’re barely experiments at all).

• Teams wait until something is perfect before they share it—killing momentum and missing opportunities for feedback.

• New ideas are siloed, so even good innovation efforts don’t build on each other.

• Top talent quietly exits, frustrated by a culture that says “innovate” but punishes failure.

In short, you’re playing it safe—and losing ground.

Why This Is a Problem

When innovation stays in the land of ideas and doesn’t translate into experimentation, it creates value-creation gaps. That means your team might be full of brilliant thinkers, but the value they’re generating doesn’t reflect that brilliance. Blockbuster, Kodak, and Blackberry all suffered from this. They didn’t lack for ideas—they lacked the courage (and structure) to act on them.

Let’s be real: your competition is not standing still. While you’re polishing your pitch deck, they’re beta-testing a half-broken product and learning fast. Innovation is not just about doing something new; it’s about doing it before someone else eats your lunch.

What You Can Do About It

The good news? Solving Incomplete Innovation isn’t about throwing out your existing systems—it’s about shifting the cultural environment. Here are some practical starting points:

• Build psychological safety so people feel safe taking risks and failing publicly.

• Start celebrating the “good failure”—the one that generated useful learning.

• Create “idea funerals” to acknowledge projects that didn’t work and honor the effort.

• Design for cross-team visibility, so innovation efforts don’t get trapped in silos.

• Allocate budgets for risk—a small pot of money each quarter for bold experiments.

This shift won’t happen overnight. But if you want real innovation—not just the concept—you have to get comfortable with messiness. You have to reward curiosity over certainty, learning over knowing, and exploration over execution (at least some of the time).

Otherwise, you’ll continue to look innovative, while quietly falling behind.

Question for Reflection:
Where in your organization are people playing it safe instead of taking smart risks, and what could you do to create a culture where experimentation is actually encouraged?

This content pulls out insights from Culture Change Made Easy by Jamie Notter and Maddie Grant. See more resources at culturechangemadeeasybook.com. 

Ask us about bulk orders of print copies for your organization, or presenting ideas from the book at your next conference or staff retreat!

We can be reached via propelnow.co or simply by replying to this email.