The Competence Trap

The better you are at your job, the less likely you are to take the kind of risks innovation requires. In many organizations, high performers unconsciously avoid innovation because they’ve been rewarded for being right, efficient, and in control. This post explores the Competence Trap—the hidden cultural dynamic where being good becomes the enemy of getting better—and how to break free without sacrificing quality.

The Competence Trap—When Being Good at Your Job Makes You Worse at Innovation

Let’s start with a paradox:
The people best positioned to innovate in your organization may be the least likely to do it.

Why? Because they’ve spent years building credibility through competence. They’ve learned to be reliable. Efficient. Accurate. Their success comes from doing things well and not messing up.

But here’s the problem: innovation requires messing up. It demands failure, uncertainty, and trying things that might not work. In other words, the very behaviors that built your top performers’ reputations are the ones they now need to unlearn if they’re going to drive innovation.

Welcome to the Competence Trap.

What Is the Competence Trap?

The Competence Trap occurs when a strong emphasis on professional competence and consistency actually inhibits learning, exploration, and risk-taking. In cultures that prize reliability above all else, people become hesitant to:

• Propose ideas they’re not 100% sure will work

• Take on projects outside their proven skill set

• Try something that might fail publicly

• Challenge norms that have brought them previous success

Over time, competence becomes a kind of performance armor—protecting people’s status, but keeping innovation at arm’s length.

How the Competence Trap Shows Up

🧩 Perfectionism disguised as quality control
“I just want to make sure it’s done right” becomes an excuse for never sharing rough drafts or untested ideas.

🧩 A fear of asking naive questions
High performers avoid anything that might make them look inexperienced—even if that’s exactly what sparks breakthroughs.

🧩 An emphasis on efficiency over exploration
Innovation takes time. People stuck in the competence trap are focused on deliverables, not discovery.

🧩 Undervalued junior voices
The people most willing to take risks or ask dumb questions often feel invisible in organizations that reward only polished execution.

🧩 Managerial risk aversion
Even when individual contributors are ready to try something new, middle managers can shut it down to avoid looking bad if the experiment fails.

The Cultural Signals That Reinforce It

Here’s the tough part: this trap isn’t individual—it’s systemic. If your culture rewards only success, speed, and precision, it’s unintentionally punishing innovation.

🚨 Performance reviews that reward execution but not experimentation
🚨 Promotion paths that favor stability over invention
🚨 Recognition programs that highlight heroic delivery, not courageous learning
🚨 A history of “don’t bring me problems, bring me solutions”—which kills inquiry

Your highest performers didn’t build their competence in a vacuum—they were trained by the system to avoid failure. And now that same system expects them to innovate without reengineering the rules.

Breaking the Competence Trap (Without Breaking Your Talent)

Escaping this trap doesn’t mean lowering your standards. It means expanding your definition of what excellence looks like. Here’s how:

✅ Redefine what “good” looks like
Start rewarding people for learning, not just performing. Publicly acknowledge experiments, prototypes, and failures that created clarity.

✅ Model intellectual humility from the top
Leaders should regularly admit what they don’t know, ask naive questions, and share lessons from experiments that didn’t pan out.

✅ Create “experimental zones”
Designate teams or projects where innovation is the goal—not flawless execution. Lower the risk by framing it as structured discovery.

✅ Encourage “bad drafts”
Make it safe (and expected) to share early-stage, messy ideas. Treat them as starting points, not liabilities.

✅ Reward risk-takers—even if they fail
If someone tries something bold and it flops, don’t sideline them. Celebrate the learning and move them to the next experiment.

✅ Train managers to manage uncertainty
Middle managers need tools and mindsets for navigating the fuzzy zone between “tried-and-true” and “might-be-brilliant.”

The Goal: Competence AND Courage

Your top performers have valuable skills—but if they stay in the Competence Trap, they’ll never stretch into the kind of innovators your organization actually needs.

The good news? These are people who know how to learn. But you have to make it safe—and even prestigious—for them to take the risk of learning out loud.

Because the truth is: real innovation won’t come from the rebels on the fringe. It’ll come when your A-players feel free to experiment.

Question for Reflection:

Are your high performers being incentivized to keep doing what they’re already good at—or to take risks and grow in new directions? What’s one way you could make innovation safer for your most competent people?

This content pulls out insights from Culture Change Made Easy by Jamie Notter and Maddie Grant. See more resources at culturechangemadeeasybook.com. 

Ask us about bulk orders of print copies for your organization, or presenting ideas from the book at your next conference or staff retreat!