Innovation Without Experimentation Is Just Talk

Innovation isn’t a strategy deck—it’s a behavior. And if your organization isn’t actively testing, failing, and learning, you’re not innovating—you’re ideating. In this post, we examine the difference between talking about innovation and actually doing it. We’ll explore how to recognize when your team is stuck in “innovation theater,” and what it takes to build a culture where experimentation is expected, supported, and resourced.

Innovation Without Experimentation Is Just Talk

Let’s say your organization has a great track record of producing smart ideas. Your meetings are full of creative brainstorming. People get excited about blue-sky thinking. You’ve probably even hosted an innovation retreat or two.

But here’s the critical question: how many of those ideas actually got tested?

Because unless your team is experimenting, you’re not innovating—you’re performing innovation. You’re caught in what many call “innovation theater”: all the visuals, none of the substance.

This is one of the key traps of Incomplete Innovation. The cultural signals say “we value creativity,” but when it comes to execution—especially the messy, risky part of trying things out—everything slows to a crawl. Or worse, nothing happens at all.

Why Organizations Avoid Experimentation

Experimentation is inherently uncomfortable. It introduces risk. It invites failure. It surfaces inconvenient truths. So even if innovation is encouraged on paper, real-life barriers kick in fast:

• Fear of looking incompetent. Teams don’t want to be associated with an idea that didn’t work.

• Perfectionism. Experiments get bogged down by overplanning—no one wants to ship until it’s “just right.”

• Lack of time or resources. Innovation becomes “nice to have,” shoved to the edges of already-full workloads.

• Unclear permission. People don’t know if they’re really allowed to experiment, so they default to the safest path.

The irony? Most orgs are optimizing like pros—tight processes, clear deliverables, predictable outcomes. But those same strengths are what kill innovation. Because innovation isn’t predictable. It’s a bet.

Innovation Requires Learning Loops, Not Finished Products

Organizations often confuse innovation with output. But real innovation is about learning. It’s about asking:

• What happens if we try this?

• What did we learn?

• What do we need to try next?

Without that feedback loop, you’re not innovating—you’re just making things more complicated. And that leads to innovation stalling out after a few big ideas, with no system in place to translate them into new value.

🚨 Real-world example:

A global nonprofit launched a cross-functional “innovation task force” with tons of energy behind it. They gathered ideas, held design sprints—and then… nothing. Why? Because no one budgeted for testing. Great ideas died on the whiteboard. Innovation theater at its finest.

What a Culture of Experimentation Looks Like

To make innovation real, you need to institutionalize experimentation—bake it into how your organization works. Here's what that looks like in practice:

✅ Rapid testing cycles.
Instead of waiting for fully built products, teams test assumptions fast and often—minimum viable pilots, user tests, early prototypes.

✅ Clear tolerance for failure.
Experiments are designed with the expectation that some will fail. That’s the point.

✅ Visibility across teams.
Everyone sees what’s being tested, what’s been learned, and how those insights are influencing strategy.

✅ Time and money reserved for risk.
Innovation isn’t “extra credit”—it’s resourced. A portion of team budgets is carved out for learning-oriented experiments.

✅ Leadership that models the mess.
Leaders go first by admitting what they don’t know, showing vulnerability around testing, and celebrating learning—not just outcomes.

Start Small, But Start Now

You don’t have to overhaul your entire organization to get out of innovation theater. You just have to create one place where real experimentation can thrive.

Pick one team. One product. One assumption that hasn’t been tested. And give someone the air cover to run an experiment. Create a rhythm of checking in—not just on results, but on what was learned. And then build from there.

If you want to be innovative, you have to design for experimentation—not just talk about it.

Question for Reflection:

What’s one assumption your team has made recently that hasn’t been tested—and what kind of small, fast experiment could help you learn more before committing resources?

This content pulls out insights from Culture Change Made Easy by Jamie Notter and Maddie Grant. See more resources at culturechangemadeeasybook.com. 

Ask us about bulk orders of print copies for your organization, or presenting ideas from the book at your next conference or staff retreat!

We can be reached via propelnow.co or simply by replying to this email.